#6, Nobody is arguing in favor of piracy. I'm only saying that there is good reason for Microsoft to go public with these two product IDs.
#4, Fine. He's out the door (in my example, he was already laid off), but firing him doesn't solve everything for the poor schmucks left behind. Microsoft is simply giving organizations a chance to check their product ID's. If there's a match, then they know what has happened and can deal with it accordingly. If he did work for your company, you would want to know these product IDs just to figure out what he did and fire him for it, unless he simply admits it.
There are umpteen gazillion admins in the world who still remember the old days when you could get away with typing ten 1's in the CD Key of most Microsoft products. Later, the eleven digit CD Keys would typically accept ten 1's followed by a 2. Heck, plenty of Microsoft employees used this trick internally. Sometimes the excuse was to save a few seconds. Sometimes it was because people took their CDs out of jewel cases and put them in carrying cases, but Microsoft stuck the CD Key sticker directly to the jewel case instead of the insert, so there was no easy way to keep the sticker with the CD.
In the past, once you got past install, there was never any ramifications from using the wrong CD Key, and it continued to work on product after product. So I can understand why some people might have assumed that the XP key didn't matter once you got past activation. (The product ID is not the same as the key, and the key is never displayed after activation.)
In my example, the admin had the legal key back at his desk. But until you print it out from the Microsoft eOpen web site, all Volume License customers have to log onto that SSL site using a Passport to get their keys. That site isn't always up, it isn't always tolerably fast, and Passport's reliability/speed doesn't help. The company's eOpen account might be tied to the Passport of someone who is unavailable. There are all kinds of reasons that people might have difficulty getting their hands on their correct legal key. I'm not saying that they should use a pirate key. That's definitely wrong. But there are clearly factors which might have caused average Joes to do the wrong thing, and there needs to be a way to identify what's happened and move forward.
|