The Active Network
ActiveMac Anonymous | Create a User | Reviews | News | Forums | Advertise  
 

  *  

  Vista screams past XP in gaming tests!
Time: 11:52 EST/16:52 GMT | News Source: ZDNet | Posted By: Robert Stein

Sorry for the exclamation point in the headline, but my inner media critic, who is taking over for the second half of this post, insisted on it. It’s there for a reason, which I’ll get to shortly, I promise. [Update: My inner media critic is laughing out loud at the people who completely missed this reference and posted TalkBack comments complaining about the headline. “See,” he says, “you should have used FOUR exclamation points. Then maybe they would have figured out the headline was deliberately sensational, to make a point about how important headlines and opening pages are to media coverage.”] Our technical press, like the mainstream media, sometimes has a hard time letting go of an idea it’s been pushing. That’s true even when new facts show that the old story wasn’t, strictly speaking, accurate. Or when facts on the ground have changed and maybe it’s time to alert your readers to the new realities. Today’s case in point: I just got through reading ExtremeTech’s recent lab-based head-to-head comparison of gaming performance in Windows Vista SP1 and XP SP3. The conclusion was quite a surprise.

Write Comment
Return to News

  Displaying 1 through 25 of 146
Last | Next
  The time now is 6:21:23 PM ET.
Any comment problems? E-mail us
#1 By 89153 (75.157.154.187) at 5/29/2008 12:07:44 PM
No it doesn't

http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=1939

#2 By 2332 (66.92.78.241) at 5/29/2008 12:14:41 PM
#1 - While I agree that it, for the most part, doesn't "scream" past XP, it does do better on virtually every test, with the greatest difference between more than 16%.

In other words, Vista SP1 is FASTER than XP SP2 or XP SP3.

Since people are constantly claiming that Vista is slower than XP, the headline was justified.

In addition, most people who read ExtremeTech are people obsessed with every FPS they can squeeze out of their machines. They spend hours tweaking BIOS settings, downloading hacked drivers, and spending insane cash on special ram that can be over clocked.

The revelation that Vista SP1 will gain them 2 FPS is more than enough to get them to switch. If you doubt this, you're probably not part of these hobbiest communities.

#3 By 89153 (75.157.154.187) at 5/29/2008 12:28:41 PM
#2 My point is, the title of the article is nothing more than a sensationalist headline about what Adrian quite rightly points out that it should've been called:

"Vista catches up with XP … finally"

or

"Vista beats XP in photo-finish"

And enthusiasts will not rely on someone else's scores to make the choice for them. They'll do the tests themselves and look at their own numbers.


This post was edited by Flint2 on Thursday, May 29, 2008 at 12:30.

#4 By 23275 (68.186.182.236) at 5/29/2008 12:42:55 PM
Puuuuhhhreeeze READ the article.

It is much less about performance than the title suggests - the title, as an example of what the article DOES intend to convey, is how poorly the original ET article was written and edited.

The point being made is about how old data, old drivers, and old experiences are being used to perpetuate inaccurate conclusions about Windows Vista - and most especially, how the press is shaping perceptions (intentionally and according to a bias)... where... there is no evidence to support that bias. The title of the article by Ed Bott was intentionally designed to lampoon that trend.

The facts are clearer, Vista and the ecosystem around it have matured to the point where even gaming experiences are at least as good as they were on a very mature XP, and in relevant and popular cases (read, new games) even better than they were on XP - and DX10 has not even been factored!

#1, obviously, the author of that article either did not read Ed's article, or he scored very poorly on basic reading comprehension tests - and recently so....

#5 By 32810 (99.252.203.192) at 5/29/2008 1:30:38 PM
Ultimately, it's up to the individual to decide. I myself have found Vista to be more than adequate in terms of gaming. While I don't benchmark to see if there's a +/- FPS, the overall feel in games is pretty solid.

I didn't find the Extreme Tech article any different or sensationalistic than others. It states the operating systems involved, the hardware specs and the synthetic benchmarks. It's just showing that Vista needs new hardware, better driver support, and Microsoft's own updates. Some predicted that Vista would hit it's stride in mid 08 and this seems to be the case.

I don't see what all the fuss is about. Singling out Extreme Tech is nit picking while there are thousands of similar articles on the Internet.

#6 By 2332 (66.92.78.241) at 5/29/2008 2:37:27 PM
#3 - "And enthusiasts will not rely on someone else's scores to make the choice for them. They'll do the tests themselves and look at their own numbers."

Hardly. The reason sites like ExtremeTech exist is because enthusiasts rely on them to help them make purchasing decisions.

Most people can't afford to go around buying all the various products out there just to see which one gives them 3 FPS more in Crisis.

Why don't you go back and look at how long it took for XP perf in games to equal that of Win 9x. It took months if not years. Vista was no different. But your buddy Adrian doesn't seem to care about history... he just wants to bash Vista.

#7 By 11888 (70.51.90.41) at 5/29/2008 11:17:07 PM
Can hi everyone?

#8 By 62611 (67.166.83.247) at 5/30/2008 8:37:50 AM
I've been saying it for awhile now. The problem with Vista isn't Vista, it's drivers. And this proves it. I have also been saying that Nvidia has the worst drivers and it has been documented that Nvidia cards are responsible for the majority of crashes in Vista.
The test uses and ATI card and now Vista comes out ahead.
http://www.extremetech.com/article2/0,2845,2302495,00.asp

#9 By 2960 (72.196.195.185) at 5/30/2008 12:45:44 PM
#1,

That's the only article I've ever read to state the opposite. I think I'll go with the vast, VAST majority of testers on this subject.

And, of course, my own findings.

Vista lags well behind XP in every game I've tested it on. In fact games run faster on my AMD 4800x2 7800GTX system under XP than they do on my Intel E6700 8800GTX system with Vista, and that's why all my Gaming is done on the XP machine.

Not to mention there are no sound issues or continuing 8800GTX issues under XP.

It is what it is.

TL

This post was edited by TechLarry on Friday, May 30, 2008 at 12:47.

#10 By 8556 (12.206.195.4) at 5/30/2008 2:15:51 PM
TL: What would happen if you had a duplicate hard drive lying around that matches the one in your Vista machine. Why not use it to do a repair install on the Vista machine, with the Vista drive unplugged of course. Run tests with identical hardware with the latest SP's and drivers on each system. How similar do they run now? Apples and oranges comparison, as valid as they may seem to someone, are not science.

#11 By 3746 (72.12.161.38) at 5/30/2008 3:12:49 PM
I have an 8800GTX and Vista and had no issues. My system when gaming is far more stable then XP ever was. I play TF2 all the time and the system is rock solid. Bioshock all the way through without a crash. Unless you are doing apples to apples test you can't know that one machine is faster. I have XP on another drive and there is no noticeable difference in speed or video quality between XP and Vista. And Vista wins for stability on my machine. It is amusing that someone would slag a scientific apples to apples test because their gut tells them something. Maybe the Vista haters want to hate it so much that they will believe anything even when the evidence shows them the contrary.

#12 By 868449 (27.159.225.82) at 12/7/2012 8:53:04 PM
This actually answered my dilemma, thank you!


<a href=http://www.shopjordanscheap.com/air-jordan-fusion-c-118.html>cheap jordans online for sale</a>


<a href=http://www.buyjordansgo.com/womens-jordan-shoes-c-139.html>jordan shoes for sale</a>

#13 By 4240821 (213.139.195.162) at 10/27/2023 6:52:36 AM
https://sexonly.top/get/b321/b321svbspdqzvuifrhk.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b420/b420uzyschjuaxvctzm.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b788/b788xmupfrhkenxpajt.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b316/b316hvdhzhgqczpdaps.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b754/b754hqgogfqxjmaoqhg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b700/b700voodczoyulvsixd.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b651/b651qfbpdkouqxkrhvy.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b483/b483yeycbbyvoaqxgsp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b149/b149dridwzzfkaftawg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b624/b624kbkmngfoaohxpob.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b358/b358uyhdjcxyzfnvweg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b336/b336dsqgcittvfjywws.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b527/b527dxicvgvusraclrk.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b181/b181hmxhlhobxvbeamp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b100/b100sgcslcolkjigthb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b417/b417kbvlvmrllblsskb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b626/b626cerrbbsevwawlyp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b828/b828lblvffauozbmxpe.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b163/b163mmjbdkagkmzpotb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b82/b82tcaxicebnvasswb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b791/b791uhrvigiddiecisp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b981/b981chwbhtoegqldhyp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b919/b919trjopvldyrxxcoe.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b161/b161wpdtlciyyxhlntn.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b621/b621qawbozszlwtfkcw.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b856/b856xwygdonbblxoswx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b628/b628ezmjbhfjlyhrznq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b474/b474evbntvbqpjddzye.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b980/b980wfkbqazbuiddckl.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b489/b489luaurrqytbhwxxv.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b859/b859nsvvlwvecrbmgrj.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b889/b889wqhkurbwogvgdwn.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b435/b435ybckmpjowqtfopo.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b597/b597tdbykkdqzkdzyph.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b341/b341udgjfbmkuddkbgr.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b853/b853aealkqbscxydzbg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b246/b246wktcvokifphlgcc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b631/b631tndojwwgmfpoxty.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b496/b496vfrvpnrvusansrw.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b338/b338bssuedidbxzadqd.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b894/b894tyauupwtqnmxpdd.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b21/b21lhinynjcuxxatzi.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b248/b248sqczaujixfwxbxk.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b473/b473bjflonncfnqwerq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b900/b900wdmczwkevicwkyb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b909/b909pfghgeqxmicdfzs.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b645/b645jqjkaufuhuatxua.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b18/b18rwdyzygilljcdmi.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b139/b139yhksiixhgcinqor.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b718/b718fkzuiecvazmntzz.php

#14 By 4240821 (194.226.185.83) at 10/29/2023 9:52:53 AM
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1qBW39T6zVDbBeB8qeg0uEMH8hY5ucdk
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1IH7LHFfGgblCSHJnY-ACElDXzSuufiI
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1ssMjptIVhuz1RHg-uDfXLOACtQBB5NA
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1bA62wUCgheThhJ8rSGGu2Y2JZtQUNKQ
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1AT0qTeoc656hrQwCqp6QCMTMM388feQ
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1PBAD-r3PIlPhR-Dl3Fhps0_db-sBVkk
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1eIyBNCqqmjJsSB2qEtDmMLiwW6V23iY
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1g3j6I9jxSk_r-eDgKQTqnQuZv39lR6A
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1bpmtLKA6RIS7OBbdQbI6G7U-wjt-5vU
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1jnwVlTRK_o3mP6v17hswnn-Dqvia4BM
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1X8uf3-2bkEdrAk1nHYhISlqN32Hysd8
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1MqWTk4t8u_HxTHpNqaK1YhkJMjK1MnY
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1qIMpljX9fqE3Dd_JMEFcEG8khaXudrU
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1xmF5f8EAIHfgUnlGs7PFWvsUIcPLfGI
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1h61GVmUr9wNBbl0f7GpAEEFlnOrlzZ4
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1LVQeT85kRH7dNkc4k2LciPRIOApFynk
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=19wEv0-uBQufdgm9IAa2JTYgMXgIGtYk
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1_Bf5zvRG0HrHPvHsPBoEACSVppCQpm4
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1MpKej8pFKerNUOzYTGIXdXVa1HFQjoM
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1c5Hcl7DfB0wNliv3XQkSYxdgPTnQtCM
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=19W2LRrL2WqBUQ8MKm4AlY5jpjrGQsTY
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1sp4NFf-r7HRkkxPas8D3kxTVUCbuSJU
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=10YfUofmfYjUlYn9Xgeu4uc2FDoOWGz0
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1ICHER0qtoiAqURFZPWnDv1PnwlWpjjo
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=19ZEaW4KkJ0Iic6uEN-IXg1B6NDMT30A
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=18brGtPaGLOGBXJ-mPek04HV30aLZSs0
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1NGUsu87PAxYEdUtGj3qBB02ZuRuSWWY
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1qZIP38j-KGBNsImbsq4m1z1vxEWxjjk
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1aEFJpBjMHI93RfZZ-r290GTB5cahyxA
https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1eJXVlvl-1YEJ8moA0qbJ-_LEP0vMJjA

#15 By 4240821 (103.151.103.150) at 10/30/2023 4:34:50 PM
https://www.quora.com/profile/JamesWelch159/_BeeBeeKimchi_-rubylynne-unicornjesse-Josett112-emerode-edddit-bianca_resa-Ruby-playsalot-Bria-Jaye-Love
https://www.quora.com/profile/DanielleJohnson912/reneepaige696-Sawyer-Sloane-KirstyMxoxo-Stormi-Fantasia-makoto-toda-awesome1982-Basicbossmomma-Juicypussyh
https://www.quora.com/profile/AngeloOgunlana619/Ariana-Aimes-kat3369-Kat-Lee-Kiara-Knight-Ivy8816-LunaaaLove-Ziena_Candy-KrCreme-arisa-minami-yejsusen
https://www.quora.com/profile/SusanMiller267/lillyautumn-Jade-Kitti-LexxGrey-TheLittleSuccubus-Bluejae3-Azure-Storm-Miss_Joy-joaninhahottie-Sandee143
https://www.quora.com/profile/GeorgeArroyo581/Lavenderhayz-the_lucid_muse-Svetlana-Rae-Eva-and-Pau-mimi-farra-tiedyedicorn-KittyKatKums-HOW-TWO-ENJOY
https://www.quora.com/profile/AngelaMartin393/His_meat_her_feet-HotTeacher-kkittyblue-Brazilianamateurs-HeavenlyStrawberry-madixxxo-Saragenova-teganL
https://www.quora.com/profile/RosemerySims680/Petitesweets6-bebesfuck-Pissgoddess-jade-lee-1-DeliahSketcher-Alexxx_boo-Jenny-Couture-Sirs_snowbunny-Kb
https://www.quora.com/profile/BrookMiller188/SamanthaNMike-vickythomson-MiaTHAfreak-SushiSlut-DreamQueenV-BanksLikeTyra-srgiomraz28-electrareyna-Viol
https://www.quora.com/profile/JenniferBogdan560/SugarPissPrincess-Carvisk-Erzsebet-L3wd-Waifu-Miss-Rochelle-Laceypage88-KCUndercovers-Kerriraye-RandR436
https://www.quora.com/profile/AnnaBeyl433/Fuckhothuswife-lisaisamor-michaela-sabbatini-Adrianna-Evans-FukaShark-SpoiledPrincess30-reyreymarie-pleasu

#16 By 4240821 (103.152.17.80) at 10/31/2023 7:40:39 AM
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97561
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97873
https://app.socie.com.br/MishaCrossSophiaLove
https://app.socie.com.br/dustinizzyStephanieWylde
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/98265
https://app.socie.com.br/SubmissivehunSheGotIt909
https://app.socie.com.br/vanpsuicideMissVal18
https://app.socie.com.br/starstaxxShyGirl8889
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97179
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97486

#17 By 4240821 (103.151.103.150) at 10/31/2023 3:06:20 PM
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/98044
https://app.socie.com.br/genevese1aaliyahgisele
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/98326
https://app.socie.com.br/racyrachelselenderosa
https://app.socie.com.br/TaliaGarciaapril_raee
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97506
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97506
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97514
https://app.socie.com.br/sofibalslg987lg987
https://app.socie.com.br/SugarSquirts1sexekitten69

#18 By 4240821 (62.76.146.75) at 11/1/2023 1:09:01 PM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=1009&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=16484&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=55690&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=61969&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=83445&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=25481&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=35159&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=4851&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=777&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=26973&Group=Last

#19 By 4240821 (2.57.151.31) at 11/1/2023 11:58:29 PM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=31240&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=66061&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=83423&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=31226&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=84180&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=14210&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=73633&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=80602&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=14235&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=20759&Group=Last

#20 By 4240821 (109.94.218.82) at 11/2/2023 2:48:48 PM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=14009&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=18199&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=12616&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=61746&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=85217&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=8762&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=21777&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=65826&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=20988&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=38679&Group=Last

#21 By 4240821 (212.193.138.10) at 11/3/2023 6:12:14 AM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=20684&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=6707&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=23337&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=23560&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=5417&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=13005&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=20916&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=41105&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=56016&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=17073&Group=Last

#22 By 4240821 (109.94.216.41) at 11/5/2023 6:31:06 AM
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/664565961
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/649273428
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/649967961
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/658645580
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/653826963
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/650436702
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/656799525
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/650013932
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/651049103
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/653540235

#23 By 4240821 (92.119.163.194) at 11/6/2023 5:29:58 AM
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19909576
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19909547
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19909422
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19893825
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19912594
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19900975
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19896907
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19909486
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19894804
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19893276

#24 By 4240821 (62.76.146.75) at 11/8/2023 5:30:08 PM
https://www.hackerearth.com/@tacursepar1980
https://www.hackerearth.com/@swearinlosil1974
https://www.hackerearth.com/@latinonpchec1984
https://www.hackerearth.com/@ligfsaderank1975
https://www.hackerearth.com/@spirisalsie1972
https://www.hackerearth.com/@tioraistatran1971
https://www.hackerearth.com/@lupridddrawder1989
https://www.hackerearth.com/@dingparnfarte1983
https://www.hackerearth.com/@imovines1979
https://www.hackerearth.com/@mesmaijamast1975

#25 By 4240821 (45.146.26.215) at 11/10/2023 5:45:32 PM
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109173007
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109115208
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109051916
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109171559
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231110010448
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109083427
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109055719
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109142003
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109065450
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231110000204

Write Comment
Return to News
  Displaying 1 through 25 of 146
Last | Next
  The time now is 6:21:23 PM ET.
Any comment problems? E-mail us
User name and password:

 

  *  
  *   *