"An MCE PC is too expensive to be attractive for the average user."
Not if it's main their desktop and only computer. I don't see people buying MCE's for the sole purpose of having a Media Center. If you buy an MCE, the benefit is that you have a computer it INCLUDES the Tivo like features.
So, if you have someone who wants to buy a new computer to replace an old computer OR is buying their first computer, then buying an MCE would make sense because they get Windows XP Pro system, with an MCE. This eliminates the need for an additional Tivo expense, AND the channel/listings are free, where as Tivo requires a monthly (or annual if you choose) fee.
And then if you choose, you can get an extender (Xbox, HP. Linksys) etc. to extend up to 5 different rooms. And with a TIVO, look at the feature limitations compared to an MCE. The Media Center software has a plethora more features than a TIVO.
If you have no desire to have a pc, then of course, Tivo is the way to go (or DVRs through cable companies, etc.)
|