I guess maybe it's a situation where YMMV? Here's what I've seen so far:
We have Exchange 2003 and have tried using the Verizon Samsung i600 against it using server-side ActiveSync. When it works, it works pretty well. However, ActiveSync seems to fail every so often on different attachments and even calendar items. And, once it fails on one item, it fails to complete the rest of the sync. ActiveSync as a whole seems to be rather flaky; sometimes everything is configured correctly but the device still doesn't work (requiring a reset), and the error messages often are misleading.
On the desktop side, we had a batch of Toshiba e740s. Nice devices on paper, but it was problem after problem. The battery life was really hit-or-miss. Personally, mine nearly always would work for about a week on standby, which isn't bad at all. But other users were occasionally getting less than a day, and that was with minimal use. Over the course of two years, we tried ROM updates, turning off notifications, etc. (and the wireless switch was rarely if ever turned on for most of these folks), and still some people had really lousy battery life. I saw it happen on mine as well a couple of times--I'd have it in the cradle all day, go home, not touch it, then in the morning it would show the battery as nearly dead and would turn off after a few seconds to go into standby mode. The notification LED was turned off (we had to do this as Toshiba confirmed that the "Flash light for: <n minutes>" setting actually didn't work at all, but would continue to blink indefinitely). Granted, some of these are OEM issues... but that's of little consolation to the end user struggling with their device.
I've had a BlackBerry 7100t for awhile now, and it just works slick. I do miss some of the things you can do with the PocketPC--obviously the BlackBerry does not have near the capabilities or the available software. But in a way, that's also sort of its strength--it does only what most people really want out of it (at least for now ;), but it does it very well. The sync process is much more reliable... it just works, really. And it's a true "push" technology... I was a little disappointed in the Exchange ActiveSync approach with the specially coded SMS message triggering a synchronization. The security features are also nifty (killing the device remotely is a nice function), and combined with the remote administrative features, you can tell that this is a device designed with the problems IT folks face in mind. And apparently with the upcoming BES release, the devices can be provisioned entirely from the BES console--no desktop software installation necessary as everything will be synchronized wirelessly. This is good for a number of reasons, one of which is that the Desktop Manager software uses Intellisync, which has many of the same problems as I've experienced with ActiveSync. Also, the devices are significantly cheaper.
I don't think the BES account is a huge problem, really, and it hasn't been fragile in my experience. It's true about the PDF attachments, though--if they are embedded TIFF files, for example, you get nothing. And you can't edit attachments (although this was somewhat true on the PocketPC as well--editing in Pocket Word could get you in trouble...). Rich text is lost as well, but in our situation I'm not sure that it's a real issue. But all in all, I think it's a superior solution (at the moment), especially for our users.
|