The Active Network
ActiveMac Anonymous | Create a User | Reviews | News | Forums | Advertise  
 

  *  

  A response to Richard Stallman
Time: 17:41 EST/22:41 GMT | News Source: E-Mail | Posted By: Jonathan Tigner

Thanks, BobSmith. There are a number of people in the open source pantheon, among them Bruce Perens and Eric Raymond. However, Richard Stallman, as author of the GPL and one of the most prolific authors in the open source movement, certainly fills the role of Zeus. Perens and Raymond serve many purposes, though a number of their recent writings seem aimed at channeling the open source community’s ire towards an enemy (usually Microsoft, who is portrayed as an evil Zelig that they inevitably see standing in the shadows in photo opportunities with open source critics). Stallman, however, rarely dirties his hands with such things, leaving him free to operate in the ethereal realm of open source philosophy.

Stallman serves his purpose well, even if I often disagree with him. What motivated me to write this response, however, were six simple words included in his recent article: Free software does not mean "gratis".

Write Comment
Return to News

  Displaying 1 through 25 of 314
Last | Next
  The time now is 6:15:53 AM ET.
Any comment problems? E-mail us
#1 By 4240821 (45.149.82.86) at 10/26/2023 7:08:39 AM
https://sexonly.top/get/b521/b521fdlzwkaqnddggiz.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b93/b93adaaarmqvckvnfn.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b704/b704jogyjadoxvqxmoy.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b680/b680bmxrkjyynckvjkl.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b434/b434cxelsbvjyuaitma.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b194/b194jkvomyihemgwhgf.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b470/b470tdzpjieqbmkbrxx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b384/b384dpbjofsycjfvwuz.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b15/b15ogqgqwmeppqfihb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b467/b467omhqsdpcatlveqr.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b117/b117vxfbombvbhcwzgg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b206/b206fgqhgsenpaohjsx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b214/b214jwbjphozezoimob.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b279/b279vzgckgshkidtyih.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b300/b300wxeixdfkldvjxti.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b32/b32qhagvkwpiugjuvm.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b336/b336cifacxelbtflgmx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b651/b651ptudsozqbdmkwdf.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b464/b464vivttwmicnumxzg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b594/b594iotbvktqjdwjxbm.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b138/b138nngalejfppkhunx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b535/b535tloywntywjzpfkp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b335/b335ldpzezzfppffnde.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b883/b883rdbaxvoisdvlqih.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b929/b929teruqrwlciurouc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b997/b997sycgtmsplaeztzz.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b821/b821lakwxfbwgimuefd.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b484/b484wcrufrofxfjojta.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b476/b476ljspzefdkmkbmhq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b953/b953gqcacisqeyhtniq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b953/b953yiyvhaevkjofoeo.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b613/b613xusguphpryiscnj.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b652/b652gxhxaljbqehzelf.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b931/b931aamvrhzreevlejz.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b502/b502rttpabmemickemd.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b842/b842qkvwofpmdjwzddc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b757/b757mtjgcntjeiekrxg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b862/b862kllfesdoxxklswl.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b24/b24rdcedzdikjvbyob.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b531/b531prhklwtxsgfisda.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b800/b800pfmhzsrgfyprcdk.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b371/b371uejpedtrhvksamc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b566/b566zfsisqzizkonezc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b818/b818upehbhhwyazuuyc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b294/b294urdtibghxltfgkp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b346/b346znredqurhlzyjqc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b885/b885hudhlpcmcnzztws.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b523/b523pvnfhnpsaheohny.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b117/b117ncrsbzrqubjaeug.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b427/b427vhmutxcroxriilx.php

#2 By 4240821 (103.151.103.150) at 10/30/2023 10:14:47 AM
https://www.quora.com/profile/DavidVasquez320/ANORMAL_SHOW-Hot-momma-Leslie_2021-UndyingClay-Soph_is_playing-Montana-smiles-Alexandra-Nice-MamaWithMilk
https://www.quora.com/profile/BrianSpencer806/suga6aby-Itslablonde-lovia-flame-Latinpeople-GIGI93-FFMX-Nicehotjob-kaybaexoxo5-Carrie-silverstone-Syd
https://www.quora.com/profile/ShayakBerry446/Thatwifenextdoor-Angel98xx-Lexi-Capri-AmandaFoxxxBbw-Wild_Tequilla_-MiraMonroe-Curvy_mire-CiaCreams-Toot
https://www.quora.com/profile/DavidBeckley313/Rylily-Honeypotoflove-xoDirtyKittyxo-KassandraCeleste-RosiePetalss-sultry-vixen-Rita-Faltoyano-mia-khalifa
https://www.quora.com/profile/SamFoltz962/Catalella_18-Lesbianalliecats-Moana-leesa-patricia-colegiala-ai-yuumi-Cher-Butler-AbbeySky-Beautyandessex
https://www.quora.com/profile/BonnieBrown397/eatgabby-Beautiful-Fetishes-siastorm-ALICESEXY-WaltersWalker-shannon-whirry-Scarlett-peach-Wearepeachandda
https://www.quora.com/profile/BrookMiller188/SamanthaNMike-vickythomson-MiaTHAfreak-SushiSlut-DreamQueenV-BanksLikeTyra-srgiomraz28-electrareyna-Viol
https://www.quora.com/profile/MarkWright936/SaintTigrexx-Devon_Jinxx-JuicyClitorus-novasinsane-NymphaOphis-maisapravo-chronickoba-MIA-JOCELYN-Lady-B
https://www.quora.com/profile/MariaWest444/renaissanceslut-Lolalouise-Allthafeels-roxie_trinks-Torifoxx-small_katy-Alyssabr00ke-Sneakstheminx-theki
https://www.quora.com/profile/CoryBryant916/LatinaMILFxBBC-RoseMaryWood-Kailiah27-riahhhhhhh_-HornyUniCouple-Sandy-kane-Carina-Almeida-thefoxxnextdoor

#3 By 4240821 (103.152.17.80) at 10/31/2023 10:10:59 AM
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97486
https://app.socie.com.br/AshEbonyBBWBunny
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97614
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/98270
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97614
https://app.socie.com.br/Whitneyassoryippieskip
https://app.socie.com.br/Frobbinhoodlaurenphillips
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/98311
https://app.socie.com.br/AktatatataCendal
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97887

#4 By 4240821 (103.151.103.150) at 10/31/2023 2:43:43 PM
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97418
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/98044
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97375
https://app.socie.com.br/SugarSquirts1sexekitten69
https://app.socie.com.br/WickedMexbarbaragregorio
https://app.socie.com.br/KittyMinximadisonjohnston
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97574
https://app.socie.com.br/pastelfairymagicxo
https://app.socie.com.br/Curvygirl1HazelX
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97589

#5 By 4240821 (62.76.146.75) at 11/1/2023 6:15:08 PM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=85704&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=32044&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=21762&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=38668&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=27211&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=31925&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=54201&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=1337&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=20610&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=84723&Group=Last

#6 By 4240821 (109.94.218.82) at 11/2/2023 12:10:23 PM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=72196&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=73125&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=20643&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=15180&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=2020&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=73706&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=1458&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=73933&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=76711&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=943&Group=Last

#7 By 4240821 (212.193.138.10) at 11/3/2023 4:48:12 AM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=41708&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=78386&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=21896&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=85008&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=73341&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=16383&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=18759&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=37869&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=4222&Group=Last
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=63437&Group=Last

#8 By 4240821 (109.94.216.41) at 11/4/2023 7:11:16 PM
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/655677203
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/661408041
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/652302764
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/655404304
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/652507634
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/651656702
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/659175680
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/659965164
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/651575851
https://hotslutss.bdsmlr.com/post/660937935

#9 By 4240821 (92.119.163.194) at 11/6/2023 8:48:36 AM
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19900352
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19916042
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19898301
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19895454
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19899815
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19910601
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19902399
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/posts/44894109
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19908947
https://printable-calendar.mn.co/members/19919665

#10 By 4240821 (62.76.146.75) at 11/8/2023 2:51:32 PM
https://www.hackerearth.com/@lanmondroveer1980
https://www.hackerearth.com/@worklozbehndac1986
https://www.hackerearth.com/@persubtcisa1978
https://www.hackerearth.com/@lighbhajreza1978
https://www.hackerearth.com/@acinrasu1975
https://www.hackerearth.com/@biovideri1979
https://www.hackerearth.com/@glorbandphole1980
https://www.hackerearth.com/@lisizinna1976
https://www.hackerearth.com/@descflexasoz1976
https://www.hackerearth.com/@antgaggerfe1978

#11 By 4240821 (45.146.26.215) at 11/10/2023 5:20:32 PM
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109140337
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109155923
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109183524
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109183524
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109214423
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109092738
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109193749
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109171559
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109163846
http://www.ttbizonline.com/pro/20231109074932

#12 By 4240821 (109.94.216.41) at 11/12/2023 5:44:46 AM
https://www.mddir.com/company/fawnandgames-fansly-leaked/
https://www.mddir.com/company/rainydaze-patreon-leaked/
https://www.mddir.com/company/katherine2709-onlyfans-leaked/
https://www.mddir.com/company/myia6777-onlyfans-leaked/
https://www.mddir.com/company/stacimarie69-fansly-leak/
https://www.mddir.com/company/blondiewet-onlyfans-leak/
https://www.mddir.com/company/stoneyknight-onlyfans-leak/
https://www.mddir.com/company/babypl4ything-patreon-leaked/
https://www.mddir.com/company/betty_valentine-clips4sale-leaked/
https://www.mddir.com/company/akari1089-clips4sale-leak/

#13 By 4240821 (194.190.178.141) at 11/13/2023 12:07:10 AM
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2505/720525
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2557/720297
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2646/720410
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/3622/720413
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/3742/720443
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2557/720297
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2506/720487
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2752/720417
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2557/720356
https://instem.res.in/comment/reply/2557/720220

#14 By 4240821 (45.146.26.215) at 11/14/2023 5:17:14 AM
https://telegra.ph/DaintyWilder-Cunnilingus-Clips4sale-Leaked-01-01
https://sexonly.top/get/b212/b212xfgrfukjpopfeng.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b807/b807mftfzatzalautad.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b774/b774tdbxmjoqguraewj.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b209/b209xjwfbbayxyhtyid.php
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=2720
https://sexonly.top/get/b904/b904erdkvfuudcuwpkm.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b776/b776uipmuuguzyazhhj.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b511/b511qrpzxewaihhsxgc.php
https://telegra.ph/Leah-pro-Hentai-Fansly-Leak-01-02

#15 By 4240821 (62.76.153.10) at 11/14/2023 11:11:42 PM
https://sexonly.top/get/b190/b190wgayoembidcqvqk.php
https://telegra.ph/DaintyWilder-Lake-ManyVids-Leak-01-02
https://telegra.ph/AliceDelish-Slave-Clips4sale-Leaked-01-12
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202096185
https://telegra.ph/oliviacasta-Shower-Clips4sale-Leaked-01-12
https://sexonly.top/get/b259/b259kzutsebuotwfuuo.php
https://telegra.ph/IvanaKnoll-knolldoll-Reaction-Clips4sale-Leaked-12-01
https://sexonly.top/get/b19/b19xdydufqjggaojfq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b385/b385ugawpsngpctghym.php
https://telegra.ph/IvanaKnoll-knolldoll-Big-Nipples-Patreon-Leak-12-01

#16 By 4240821 (194.226.185.83) at 11/15/2023 7:39:22 AM
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=56784
https://sexonly.top/get/b312/b312xmemvsjcxxfefcq.php
https://telegra.ph/Queeny-Love-Glamour-Boosty-Leak-11-11
https://sexonly.top/get/b779/b779oezmnkrrnywzsbo.php
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=32904
https://sexonly.top/get/b334/b334vfepyrdllggqdtt.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b60/b60ivplqojagburkup.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202059661
https://sexonly.top/get/b74/b74sogkajkziontmrn.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b499/b499kjqbdlddqaivqat.php

#17 By 4240821 (2.57.151.31) at 11/15/2023 5:46:08 PM
https://sexonly.top/get/b852/b852fulifpmlblnzzti.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b185/b185kqgzgmoydakjtui.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b406/b406fuacwrrutjldmyv.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b65/b65rtlzlivaqicgtld.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b339/b339mmhwaicuxrciard.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b956/b956xqdunnkhexuiplg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b822/b822fyyrskejexlkmsd.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202103543
https://sexonly.top/get/b1/b1pqqevaylndxbtrk.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b882/b882qzaqbwbwyytceit.php

#18 By 4240821 (103.151.103.150) at 11/16/2023 3:10:41 PM
https://telegra.ph/Amouranth-FFMM-Patreon-Leak-11-02
https://sexonly.top/get/b184/b184yjtfoahbhfhkhwy.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b243/b243cmhypsyljtllmwx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b6/b6explqejkftiaqqo.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b585/b585boakbfebsewsoea.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b955/b955uaqslscdwnhjawl.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b412/b412nkhnjrtlqqowaym.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b832/b832xfszuefpalwenvx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b869/b869zzsqdwaflcumklx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b880/b880jlishukfbtuvxul.php

#19 By 4240821 (62.76.146.75) at 11/18/2023 6:25:38 AM
https://sexonly.top/get/b140/b140jtlhamoowpxtxpx.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b431/b431ewvxtubdsswcxow.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b105/b105pjmvennmprxaueg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b581/b581ncramgllrvrrlsq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b334/b334xsigvciqztgcfbc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b57/b57qladulohcctblny.php
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=84095
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202051870
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202065995
https://sexonly.top/get/b586/b586ciqkhtqbphesvaz.php

#20 By 4240821 (212.193.138.10) at 11/19/2023 3:08:30 PM
https://sexonly.top/get/b783/b783wlwkfjigdokqaxg.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b396/b396amrskswlbtkbaey.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b769/b769gaoaidwiikvaiwb.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202061531
https://sexonly.top/get/b81/b81qegsstahnmcyzds.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b945/b945knxqekpljrnfhsm.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b635/b635liuriglzozmazee.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b569/b569rjsrciqecdewktg.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202070194
https://sexonly.top/get/b896/b896hynaibrojqvtgiy.php

#21 By 4240821 (103.152.17.80) at 11/19/2023 6:25:31 PM
https://sexonly.top/get/b353/b353tdtzgabehbrovct.php
https://app.socie.com.br/read-blog/97156
https://sexonly.top/get/b275/b275drcnbbpjzceqcnu.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b156/b156uomfensefeceuau.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202066507
https://sexonly.top/get/b686/b686xwdocyydabjmlhv.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b831/b831omgpbzvqarmhvbo.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b227/b227jnmjvdliwiyvpcp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b891/b891lqyxcanhsclloxf.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b260/b260hqysqjbjsechkhm.php

#22 By 4240821 (62.76.153.10) at 11/20/2023 3:02:07 PM
https://sexonly.top/get/b208/b208oyblecqdjegixcb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b636/b636jjmftejlobsaodj.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b181/b181ujwqzcqcfztizzy.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b671/b671kcocdtfpzmzzmzw.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b187/b187gmhttzgcjjfbiez.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b54/b54kchfpniyroollgs.php
https://forms.yandex.com/u/636d68016938720f67714b26/
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=78385
https://sexonly.top/get/b8/b8rgofnebwgujvbob.php
https://app.socie.com.br/Jenelizabethxleka_b

#23 By 4240821 (62.76.153.10) at 11/21/2023 4:48:10 AM
https://sexonly.top/get/b858/b858qbgzjygqcmgzunp.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b274/b274vyrdlvrluznazwc.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b107/b107zygihiecgyolxch.php
https://telegra.ph/Makoshake-College-ManyVids-Leak-12-07
https://telegra.ph/oliviacasta-Catsuit-Clips4sale-Leaked-01-09
https://sexonly.top/get/b611/b611pnfywadzfomuoeu.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b952/b952vchwptpgwthnajg.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202073144
https://sexonly.top/get/b661/b661nqvhytykdqsiczj.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b460/b460xumfifefkbfcste.php

#24 By 4240821 (212.193.141.142) at 11/22/2023 9:49:41 AM
https://sexonly.top/get/b44/b44ovayhapvteinccq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b6/b6edtgzxgteeplgqy.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202057014
https://sexonly.top/get/b632/b632efojatxruiivfzh.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b39/b39ijniqepflwygnkt.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b843/b843flvnhseuvfuvgjd.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b937/b937fondnsdiqopaedr.php
http://activewin.com/mac/comments.asp?ThreadIndex=64570
https://sexonly.top/get/b384/b384obpnkjqaactiadt.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b931/b931zzqedereksrqcdx.php

#25 By 4240821 (109.94.216.41) at 11/22/2023 4:14:26 PM
https://sexonly.top/get/b954/b954axcwkiayummbvnu.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b255/b255vjvmvpteorbueic.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b401/b401zthnualighxnuab.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202039337
https://sexonly.top/get/b575/b575vxhipsyxampolak.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b401/b401xcmzjtbqdkxtenq.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b671/b671ktqeokiijfienwb.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b635/b635xsvlxuxxcmbqmzr.php
https://sexonly.top/get/b841/b841sweyhyakzwmwprb.php
https://zmut.com/pin/213124562202032739

Write Comment
Return to News
  Displaying 1 through 25 of 314
Last | Next
  The time now is 6:15:53 AM ET.
Any comment problems? E-mail us
User name and password:

 

  *  
  *   *