Mr. Dee, Brian's a very straight up guy. The app is real; he's simply being fooled by a PC app (that was designed to look like the Mac UI and iTunes). Photoshop has nothing to do with it.
Consider it this way: why would the most secretive company in the industry release an "Alpha" (it came with a pathetic, non-Apple-style read-me) for an app that just features mp3 playback? With no associated QuickTime update, no CD burning, no iPod connectivity, no iTMS, no smart playlists.... um, what's to test? What's Alpha? Why would secretive Apple release an app that only demonstrates they can accomplish limited functionality, poor responsiveness, and bugginess for 10% of their best consumer app? Any hack could get such an mp3 player running in no time flat; there is nothing to test or see here at all.
I'm a little disappointed by Brian (not that he isn't frequently wrong--he is) but at least, he clearly states he knows its a real app, and he does question the authenticity of its source and purpose.
This post was edited by sodajerk on Wednesday, June 18, 2003 at 20:02.
|