J, sry, I'm just a bit annoyed at that many stupid things that are said about Palladium.
For instance, in the article you linked to by Mr. Anderson:
"There is one respect, though, in which you can't turn Fritz off. You can't make him ignore pirated software. Even if he's been informed that the PC is booting in untrusted mode, he still checks that the operating system isn't on the serial number revocation list."
I'd like to know where Mr. Anderson got this information. According to Microsoft, Palladium is absolutely opt-in. According to Microsoft you don't even have to run Palladium enabled Windows on Palladium hardware. If you don't, you don't get the benefits of Palladium, but still, it isn't mandatory. So, perhaps Mr. Anderson is full of it?
"But can't you just turn it off?
Sure - unless your system administrator configures your machine in such a way that TCPA is mandatory, you can always turn it off. You can then run your PC with administrator privileges, and use insecure applications. "
Funny, he seems to know more about Palladium than Microsoft does. Of course TCPA != Palladium, so his FAQ doesn't really even apply. Furthermore, if a company admin opts-in for all the company machines, what's wrong with that? Isn't it the admin's job to make such decisions? The admin decides what happens or doesn't happen on a company machine, that is his job.
"the European smartcard industry looks likely to be hurt, as the functions now provided by their products migrate into the Fritz chips in peoples' laptops, PDAs and third generation mobile phones. In fact, much of the information security industry may be upset if TCPA takes off. Microsoft claims that Palladium will stop spam, viruses and just about every other bad thing in cyberspace - if so, then the antivirus companies, the spammers, the spam-filter vendors, the firewall firms and the intrusion detection folk could all have their lunch stolen. "
Wait a minute? Is he saying that a competing product is bad? If my goal is to stop virii and Palladium let's me do that better than all the anti-virus software in the world, isn't it better for me to use Palladium? New products come and go all the time, should new products be prevented from coming out because they would replace existing products? That is utter foolishness.
|