I am deeply conflicted by this one - and wondering if/how many other providers and admins are, too...
On one hand I understand and even appreciate WGA - I have had slaes restored to my company because a small company supplying PC's to a competitor got butsed by WGA for disk loading. On the other side of that event, the energy and days it took to explain all of that to the client mopped up any profit we gained in the sale of some new systems - grant it, a small number.... but the point was proven and the benefit of well built and lawful systems were again demonstrated.
On TL's side of this, I can't help but look at this as just kind of icky - it just feels draconian - even a little insulting to anyone who plays by the rules and values the law. It's like being treated as though one is guilty up front and permanently so... left to continually prove otherwise.
On the technical implementation side, TL is right again... how solid is this? How proven? What is the resolution to any challenges and is Microsoft going to write/call one's customers and say... "ooops, we're sorry, TL PC's was good to go all along and we dorked up and made his/her PC's look illegit... here's some money and some software to make up. Love, Kiss, Kiss Microsoft...."
That isn't going to happen. So the builder, integrator, or worse, the customer is going to be left to prove his or her innocense - and once accused... then what? How does one recover?
And if accused, and if resolved how does this inspire confidence when a customer DOES GET burned by a disk loader?
So really WGA's software has to be perfect - networks supporting the check up have to be perfect and on and the hardware has to stay perfect, or "goody, we get to do this all over again...." So what software, networks and hardware are ever perfect and stay perfdect?
None!
It's right there in the middle of that DELTA that WGA sticks partners, admins, and customers and piracy issues aren't consistently as significant across the globe, either. They are less significant in Canda, say, or the US, than they are in China, or India, where no copyright protections exist at all.
As TL suggests, Microsoft needs to get this perfect, or we're going to eat it.
|