I remember when John Dvorak used to have meaningful things to say. Now he just makes up crap that he doesn't know squat about, hoping to get a reaction.
Microsoft hasn't merely listed apps known to break with SP2; they also published detailed explanations of exactly why apps break and how their authors could fix them, and this info has been available for months to anybody who wants it. If this is how Microsoft "intentionally" breaks competitors' products, they could have broken more by simply calling up their competitors and saying "Boo!" into the phone.
Dvorak says the list of Microsoft programs broken by SP2 is "suspicious." He never quite says why, except that there are fewer Microsoft programs on the list than non-Microsoft. Hello? There are fewer Microsoft programs on the market than non-Microsoft. Duh.
Dvorak obviously doesn't understand anything like DCOM so he focuses on the category of apps which are broken due to ports being blocked by default, but he never mentions that one of the Microsoft programs broken by this is SQL Server (all versions, including MSDE, Personal Edition, and Developer Edition which are commonly run atop XP). C'mon, John, would Microsoft really break SQL Server just for the sake of a smokescreen? We're not talking about Monster Truck Madness. This is SQL Server!
It gets more ridiculous if you look at the messages posted on Dvorak's forum. His worshippers -- er, I mean readers -- are claiming that Microsoft "disabled" niche programs like Zoom Player and Endnote. Gimme a break! I've got nothing against those programs but they are pathetically insignificant to Microsoft. Comparing them to the Microsoft vs. Lotus competition of years ago (or any of Microsoft's major competition today, such as Oracle, Java, Mozilla, iTunes, etc.) is bizarre.
|