The Active Network
ActiveWin: Reviews Active Network | New Reviews | Old Reviews | Interviews |Mailing List | Forums 
 

Amazon.com

  *  

Escape from Monkey Island

Product: Escape From Monkey Island
Company: Lucasarts
Website: http://www.lucasarts.com
Estimated Street Price: $39.95/29.99
Review By: Byron Hinson

Introduction

Probably the best graphic adventure series in PC history, Monkey Island has kept the adventure genre going almost single handedly over the years (apart from the superb Longest Journey) with Monkey Island 1-3. This new release "Escape From Monkey Island" makes the first step into 3D, but is it as bad to control as Grim Fandango or does it finally show adventure games have a big future in 3D form? Here are some of the features:

  • Fourth in the legendary Monkey Island series of graphic adventures

  • Guybrush and his friends now appear in 3D

  • New jokes, puns and insults

  • New cinematic story

  • Hundreds of puzzles

  • Dozens of rendered backgrounds

Installation and Settings

Escape From Monkey Island is the first Monkey Island release to switch to 3D, that is to say all the characters are in 3D while the backgrounds are pre-rendered. The first LucasArts adventure to use this type of 3D style was Grim Fandango, and although the gameplay was very good (and wonderfully original) the controls left a lot to be desired. So the game now requires a 3D accelerator compared to the previous three games.

mi4_start.jpg (62338 bytes) mi4_010.jpg (33932 bytes) mi4_011.jpg (38741 bytes)

Escape From Monkey Island comes on 2 CD's, and the installation ranges from 150mbs to 900+. I went with the typical installation which meant just 150mbs of space was used on my hard drive. The game doesn't have a great need to fiddle about with any settings as the game is basically ready to go straight away as there is only one resolution to choose from.

Gameplay

Review Quotes
  "The main disappointments on the graphic side are the fact that the cutscenes are not done with the in-game engine"  

If you have played the previous Monkey Island games then you'll know exactly what Escape From Monkey Island is all about. This time around Guybrush and Elaine have finally married each other and hope they can leave the bad times with Le Chuck in the past. But not everything goes to plan as they return from their Honeymoon to discover that Elaine has been declared and a new governor for the island must be elected.

mi4_001.jpg (30262 bytes) mi4_002.jpg (33142 bytes)

The basic premise of the Monkey Island games is still here in Escape From Monkey Island. While the point and click interface has now gone we are presented with the new Grim Fandango style interface which is completely keyboard or joystick controlled. Moving Guybrush around the screen is quite easy to do and doesn't take too long to get used to even if you are still used to using the mouse to move the characters around. As you move around the screen Guybrush will look at objects or characters that he can interact with, it works really well.

mi4_012.jpg (38867 bytes) mi4_018.jpg (23631 bytes) mi4_019.jpg (48064 bytes)

The gameplay hasn't changed from Monkey Island to Escape From Monkey Island one bit, you are still required to speak to characters (with 2CD's chock full of speech), use and combine objects and discover new places. The main change in Escape from Monkey Island apart from the obvious graphical differences is the increase in good jokes compared to the previous release Curse Of Monkey Island and this is mainly due to the guys who created the excellent (and still probably funniest game created) Sam and Max being the main people behind it.

Graphics and Sound

As I have mentioned a few times throughout the review, Escape From Monkey Island does away with the flat 2D graphics from the previous three Monkey Island games and brings in a new 3D look to the series, thankfully though the warmth of the characters managed to come through just as well in this new release as it did in the previous game The Curse Of Monkey Island which was and still is a beautiful game to look at and play.

mi4_003.jpg (34077 bytes) mi4_004.jpg (43570 bytes) mi4_005.jpg (40511 bytes)

The main disappointments on the graphic side are the fact that the cutscenes are not done with the in-game engine but by full motion video which although fun to watch, would be even better if done via the engine and the final and worst part altogether the rather high amount of jaggies (due to you only being able to play in 640x480) that infest the game.

mi4_006.jpg (39597 bytes) mi4_008.jpg (42645 bytes) mi4_009.jpg (41352 bytes)

Soundwise you can never fault Lucasarts games, it is superb all the way through with bucket loads of dialogue squeezed onto the two CD's. Musically Escape From Monkey Island has hardly changed from the last Monkey Island release, but then again it didn't really have to as there was nothing wrong with the music in Curse Of Monkey Island to warrant a change.

Final Comments

How It Grades
  Originality: 80%
Gameplay: 90%
Story: 90%
Graphics: 87%
Cutscenes: 85%
Sound: 92%
Music: 88%
Manual: 80%
Interface: 90%
Multiplayer: N/A
Overall: 90%

 

Escape from Monkey Island has managed to keep the spirit of the Monkey Island series intact and take it to a new level with some great 3D graphics (If a little jagged around the edges). The laughs may not be in the game as much as they were in Monkey Island 1+2 but the jokes seem to appear more regularly than in Escape From Monkey Island. Yet another good adventure release from the guys who do it best.

 

 

Specs & Package
Overall Score 90%
Version Reviewed Escape From Monkey Island 1.1
Release Date Out Now
In The Box? 1 CD-ROM
1 Manual
The Good Points Funny
Good Puzzles
Good Story
Excellent Voice Acting
The Bad Points Jagged Graphics
Not as funny as parts 1+2
Similar To Grim Fandango
The Longest Journey
Reviewers PC Setup Pentium II 450
Windows Me
128 Meg SD-Ram
Matrox G400 32MB AGP Graphics Card
DirectX 7.1a
SoundBlaster Live! Value
17" LG Electronics Monitor
Microsoft Force Feedback Pro
Microsoft Game Pad Pro (USB)
Microsoft Digital Sound System 80
Microsoft Intellimouse Explorer

DVD TV Player - Pioneer DV-626D
Widescreen TV - Sony KV-28WS2U 28"
DVD-ROM: Toshiba SD-1202

PC Required Windows 95/98/ME Or Win 2000
Pentium 133mhz
32 MB Ram
DVD-ROM Drive
Mouse and Keyboard
640*480 video card with 8mb ram
Windows compatible sound device
155 MB of free hard drive space

 

  *  
  *   *